Cinematic overhead shot of a rustic wooden table with festive kraft paper gift bags, scattered craft supplies like googly eyes, red pom-poms, and jute twine, and a completed reindeer bag, all illuminated by warm golden hour light.

Gift Bag Ideas That’ll Make Your Presents Look Actually Good

The Paper Bag Glow-Up

Basic brown paper bags are your blank canvas, and you don’t need an art degree to make them shine.

I started with kraft paper bags from my pantry last Christmas when I ran out of wrapping supplies at 10 PM.

Best decision ever.

Santa sacks from old pillowcases save you money and look charming as hell—just add a drawstring and maybe some fabric paint if you’re feeling fancy.

Gingerbread house paper bags need nothing more than white paint and a steady hand to create those iconic frosting details on brown paper.

For rustic vibes, grab some burlap bags and go wild with:

  • Stencils and acrylic paint
  • Jute twine wrapped around the top
  • Small bells that jingle when you shake them
  • Stamps with holiday designs

Reindeer bags became my go-to for kids’ presents because children can help make them—brown paper, googly eyes, red pom-pom nose, done.

A rustic Christmas gift wrapping station featuring kraft paper bags on a wooden table, illuminated by golden hour light. The scene includes spools of jute twine, acrylic paint bottles, holiday stencils, and decorative scissors, with a handmade reindeer-themed gift bag in the foreground adorned with googly eyes and a red pom-pom nose, surrounded by pine sprigs and cinnamon sticks, all in a warm, cozy atmosphere.

I also love fringe Christmas tree bags made by layering green tissue paper and cutting it into strips that cascade down like branches.

Triangle bags work perfectly for small jewelry or candy—download a template online, fold, tape, and you’ve got geometric packaging that looks expensive.

My favorite hack? Santa belt bags using red paper, a strip of black ribbon around the middle, and a gold or silver buckle cut from cardstock.

Hand-lettered bags let you write “Merry Christmas, you filthy animal” or whatever message matches your family’s humor on plain brown paper.

Fabric Bags That Keep On Giving

Disposable gift bags fill landfills faster than you can say “environmental guilt.”

Fabric bags solve that problem while looking ten times better.

I made reusable felt gift bags three years ago for my family, and they still use them for birthdays, holidays, and random Tuesday gift exchanges.

Decorate them with:

  • Christmas trees cut from green felt
  • Mistletoe with white berries
  • Bright buttons sewn in patterns
  • Sequins if you’re feeling extra

Drawstring fabric bags work for gifts AND future storage—your recipient gets two presents in one.

An overhead shot of a crafting workspace featuring pastel felt materials, delicate embroidery scissors, and small glass bowls with sequins. The scene includes emerald green Christmas tree appliqués and soft white drawstring bags in various stages of completion, all bathed in gentle morning light that highlights the sage green, cream, and soft gold color scheme.

My sister uses hers for travel jewelry storage now.

Crochet gift bags take time but create heirloom-quality packaging that people genuinely treasure.

I can’t crochet to save my life, but my aunt makes them every year and honestly, people get as excited about the bag as the gift inside.

Decoration Tricks That Actually Work

Plain bags need personality, and you don’t need fancy supplies to give it to them.

Colored pencil polka dots became my signature after I traced around tape rolls to create perfect circles on kraft bags.

No paint, no mess, just dots in rainbow colors.

Paper streamers from the dollar store glued in stripes or swirls add instant party vibes.

Cut hearts from different colored paper, layer them, and glue them to your bags for Valentine’s or birthday presents.

Whimsical Valentine's Day gift bag design station featuring blush pink and crimson craft supplies, heart-shaped paper cutouts, watercolor markers, and decorative pom-poms on a distressed white wooden surface, with bags showcasing layered paper hearts and lace trim, illuminated by soft, diffused natural light.

Decorative pom poms changed my gift-wrapping game completely.

Instead of bows that flatten in transit, pom poms stay fluffy and fun:

  • Single large pom pom as a modern bow replacement
  • Multiple small pom poms glued randomly for texture
  • White pom poms clustered together like snowballs for winter gifts
  • Rainbow pom poms for kids’ birthday presents

Twine wrapped 5-6 times around a bag creates visual interest without covering your design.

Use markers, paints, or crayons directly on kraft or butcher paper—imperfect designs look handmade and intentional.

Other easy additions:

  • Ribbons in colors that match your wrapping paper stash
  • Stickers strategically placed (not covering the whole bag like a 6-year-old)
  • Lace trim along the top edge for elegant occasions
  • Scalloped tops cut with pinking shears

What To Actually Put Inside Goodie Bags

Empty bags are just containers, so let’s fill them with stuff people actually want.

For art-loving kids:

  • Mini colored pencil sets
  • Small sketch pads
  • Puffy paint tubes
  • Travel watercolor palettes

For coffee addicts:

  • Specialty coffee from local roasters
  • A mug that doesn’t say “World’s Best [Generic Title]”
  • Biscotti or coffee cookies

For gardeners:

  • Seed packets (tomatoes, herbs, wildflowers)
  • Small gardening gloves
  • Tiny terracotta pots

For sweet tooths:

  • Homemade cookies in cellophane
  • Artisan candies
  • Hot chocolate mix with mini marshmallows

For office warriors:

  • Quality notebooks with thick paper
  • Pens that don’t skip
  • Cute sticky notes
  • Small USB drives

For spa lovers:

  • Silk sleep masks
  • Bath bombs that don’t stain your tub
  • Face masks
  • Scented candles

For creative kids:

  • Mini Play-Doh containers
  • Coloring books with decent paper quality
  • Bubble solution
  • Sticker sheets

I always throw in one unexpected item—a book of matches from a fancy restaurant, a weird keychain, a single high-quality

Pin This Now to Remember It Later
Pin This

Similar Posts